YEAR 2022-23
EXAM CANDIDATE ID: |
XRNQ0 |
MODULE CODE: |
GEOG0093 |
MODULE NAME: |
Conservation and Environmental Management |
COURSE PAPER TITLE: |
The Social Impacts of Conservation, Oyster Habitat Restoration, and Improving Social Assessments |
WORD COUNT: |
1,742 |
Details of fieldwork project
Project title |
The Social Impacts of Conservation, Oyster Habitat Restoration, and Improving Social Assessments |
Subject keywords (please provide 3) |
Social Impacts, Assessment, Conservation |
Project location (country and region) |
Essex, United Kingdom |
Fieldwork dates |
From January 2024 to March 2024 |
Total number of days in the field |
91 |
4. Abstract
Conservation projects are now not only assessed by their ecological effectiveness, but also by how well they gain local support and avoid negative effects on human well-being (Milner- Gulland et al., 2014; Bennett et al., 2019). While evaluations of social impact assessment have been undertaken (de Lange et al., 2015), recently, little attention has been spent on refining techniques and practicing improvements suggested in the past (Margoluis et al., 2009). In response to this lack of engagement, the research will compile suggestions made by assessments, refine them, and test them when undertaking its own assessment of the social impacts of oyster habitat restoration. Located in Essex, the research will assess the ENORI project and its goal of protecting cultural value (ENORI, 2023).
6. Aims and objectives of project
The research aims to cultivate an effective approach to the assessment of social impacts made by conservation projects based on the findings of past evaluations (Jones et al., 2017). Doing so would offer project stakeholders an example of how they could approach their social impact assessments so that they collect representative data which helps improve their public relations and their project as a result (Bennett, 2016; Bennett et al., 2019). This cultivated approach will be tested, and subsequently evaluated, during its assessment of the ‘ENORI’ oyster habitat restoration project, a branch of conservation which has historically been assessed mainly by its economic and ecological impacts (Coen and Luckenbach, 2000; McAfee et al., 2020).
The conceptual side of this research will compile and draw from journals, articles, and reports. The empirical side of the research will interview ENORI project stakeholders and team members, alongside locals in Essex coastal communities. These interviews will be undertaken in collaboration with the ENORI project itself and the Tollesbury & Mersea Native Oyster Fishery Co Ltd, a partner of the project. The research will contribute empirically to the ‘ENORI’ project’s heritage-based goal, and conceptually to conservation projects of all types through the improvement of their own social impact assessments.
The research objectives are:
1) To evaluate the approaches to social impact assessment suggested by previous research
2) To create a refined approach based on this previous research
3)To test this new approach trough the assessment of the ENORI oyster habitat management project’s social impacts via interviews
4) To contribute to the ‘ENORI’ project though the sharing of collected data
5) To impact the approach to social impact assessments by conservation projects
7. Proposed research
In the modern world, conservation projects can be scrutinised based not just on their ecological results, but also their social impacts. This has sparked an interest within projects to assess the social impacts they are having on local communities and public observers (Kaplan-Hallam and Bennett, 2017), and to also focus on and marketing positive social effects as an actual part of their project’s aims (Browder, 2002). Projects assessing their social impact is important to them maintaining positive public relations (Bennett et al., 2019) and their project’s development, but a common problem is that projects struggle to develop effective methods of social impact assessment (Stem et al., 2005). In response, many evaluations of these social impact assessments have been undertaken (Wilder and Walpole, 2008; de Lange et al., 2015).
However,a key issue is that very few investigations have been conducted in order look over the suggestions made by these evaluations, and to use their suggestions to create new and improved approaches to social impact assessment (Margoluis et al., 2009). Its this lack of engagement and activity that this research will address. This research’s compiling of multiple social impact assessment evaluations will help identify effective approaches and suggestions made by these evaluations. This knowledge will subsequently be used to refine and create a new approach to social impact assessment. Though this part of the research would be conceptual, empirical evidence for its effectiveness would then be collected though its use in assessing the ENORI project.
The Essex Native Oyster Restoration Initiative (ENORI) is an oyster habitat restoration project. Its goal is to reintroduce and conserve self-sustaining European native oyster (Ostrea edulis, Linnaeus, 1758) populations within the Blackwater, Crouch, Roach and Colne Estuaries of Essex, UK (ENORI, 2023). O. edulis has been in decline across Europe due to overharvesting, habitat degradation, and disease (Gaffney, 2006), but EDNORI aims to promote sustainable fishing, and to also protect Essex’s oyster fishing heritage and long history of native-oyster fishing (ENORI, 2023).
The impact of this social goal is what the empirical part of this research will focus on. In partnership with ENORI and the Tollesbury & Mersea Native Oyster Fishery Co Ltd , interviews based around this goal with ENORI stakeholders and team members, and with local Essex coastal community members, will provide data on the social impacts ENORI has had oncostal Essex communities. The assessment approach created by the conceptual side of this research would then be tested through its assessment of this data.
The following plan denotes how the research will achieve its previously stated objectives; number filled brackets will identify which research objectives are being met:
1. The researcher will conduct an extensive literature review of social impact assessment evaluations. Reviewed literature will be primarily made up of journals, articles, and reports. During this review, assessment approaches suggested or promoted by evaluators will be compiled. Once the literature review has concluded, the complied approaches will be further reviewed, providing inspiration for a quality assessment redesign supported by evidence. During this time of literature review, the researcher will also be in contact with ENORI, the Tollesbury & Mersea Native Oyster Fishery Co Ltd, and coastal community members. This will be done in order to prepare for data collection, plan transport and journeys, and to arrange dates with interviewees. (1, 2)
2. The researcher will choose interviewees based on their knowledge of ENORI, their knowledge of local Essex communities, or their knowledge of the impacts ENORI has had on the local communities. It will be expected that interviewees will not have in depth knowledge of every aspect, but by carefully choosing a mosaic of interviews, the researcher will gain an appropriate picture of ENORI and Essex. It is expected that new interviewees may make themselves known during data collection. (3)
3. Once a refined social impact assessment has been created, the researcher will travel to Essex and carry out their interviews. Questions will be carefully chosen based on what the interviewee knows, and influenced by the assessment created by the conceptual part of this research . Standard questions asked to all interviewees will also be asked. Virtual interviews will be carried out as well if needed. Locations for the interview will be agreed; this could be at their home or elsewhere. (3)
4. Once interviews have concluded, the researcher will undertake data analysis. The data collected will also be shared with ENORI. Results from the analyses, along with how effective it was to use during data collection, will determine how the newly created assessment is evaluated. (4)
5. A report of the research and its findings will be shared with ENORI stakeholders, while the research’s findings will be published as an academic report. (4,5).
Timeline
September 2023 – January 2024: Literature review, communications with collaborators
January – March 2024: Interviews in Essex
March – July 2024: Data Analysis
July – October 2024: Ready reports
8. In country collaborations and local benefits
The research will be carried out in collaboration with ENORI, and the Tollesbury & Mersea Native Oyster Fishery Co Ltd. Data collected would benefit ENORI, as the project could use the data for information on the social impact they’ve had on local communities. Depending on what the data looks like, the local communities could also benefit from ENORI amending possible negative social impacts from its project, or bolstering positive ones.
9. How will the project further geographical knowledge?
The research will provide the field of conservation with a modern example of a social impact assessment approach. This approach will be a refined product of inspiration gathered from multiple social impact assessment evaluations, addressing the current inactivity within this branch of conservation science. The data collected by the new approach, along with its evaluation, will provide conservation practitioners with a review of this new approach, allowing them to possibly adopt aspects of the approach for their own projects. It also provides data on the social impacts of oyster habitat restoration projects, an impact of oyster habitat restoration not usually investigated.
The research and its results are intended to be published within The Social Science Journal.
10. Project outcomes and wider significance
The data collected by the research can be used by ENORI to evaluate its project’s social impacts on local Essex communities. As a result, ENORI would be able to address and negative impacts they are having on local communities, improving public relations between themselves and local Essex communities and perhaps removing impacts which are negatively affecting the community’s wellbeing. The publication of this research would also have the capacity to help conservation projects of all types, not just oyster habitat restoration. This is because the review of a newly created and refined social impact assessment approach could provide conservation projects with inspiration and evidence to improve their won social impact assessments. Similar to Essex, these changes in could also benefit their project’s local communities.
For non-academic audiences, the research would provide an insightful investigation into the social affects conservation projects can have on local communities, both good and bad. This research may introduce readers to how conservation projects include social elements as well, not just ecological ones. Readers not interested in oyster reef restoration can find benefits from this research for conservation projects of any type around the world.
12. Summary of key elements of ethical assessment
The social interaction consistently present within this research would cause most ethical issues. The key issue would be the interviews. To ensure interviewees are comfortable and do not feel harassed, the ability for an interviewee to not answer a question, stop the interview, and leave the interview must be allowed and made known to them. Interviewees must also not be forced or coerced into taking part in an interview. Any children who are interviewed must be accompanied by an adult or legal guardian, and strict permission to undertake the interview must be received by said adult or guardian. Permission must be given by each interviewee for their answers to be used in published data.
All these ethical issues will be appropriately addressed by the researcher.
版权所有:编程辅导网 2021 All Rights Reserved 联系方式:QQ:99515681 微信:codinghelp 电子信箱:99515681@qq.com
免责声明:本站部分内容从网络整理而来,只供参考!如有版权问题可联系本站删除。